Finance Bill : FM makes subtle changes in I-T Act; proposes institution of Tax Return Preparers
By B K Sinha, Former Revenue official
NEW DELHI, Feb 28, 2006 : THOUGH there is no change in the direct tax rates but Mr PC has made quite a few significant changes, much ahead of the full-fledged Act he proposes to bring in this fiscal. To begin with, he has introduced a new theory of compliance. As per new section 80AC assessees who seek relief u/s 80IA, 80IAB and 80IB have to file their returns by due date, otherwise they will forfeit the benefit under those sections. The provision will be rather harsh in cases where there is good reason for the delay. A deduction or exemption is integral to the computation process and perhaps cannot be taken away as a penalty for late filing of return. A penalty like this cannot be disguised and would be incongruous in the overall scheme of the Act.
A New Institution Created - S.139B
A new institution of Tax Return Preparers (TRP) has been provided in the Finance bill. They are authorized to prepare and file returns for the non-corporate assessees whose accounts are not statutorily auditable. Chartered accountants should not complain now.
Anonymous Donations
Donations, in the first place cannot be classified as ‘income’ of a person. However, this is now treated as income for charitable and religious institutions, unless it is a ‘corpus’ donation.
Now, all non-specific anonymous donations, where name and address are not properly mentioned will not only be treated as income but will also be taxed at the highest rate of 30%.
Of course, purely religious institutions will not be affected. For example; Tirupati, Churches, Mosques et al.
Payment of Interest not recognised unless actually paid
Where interest is converted as loan, by the lender, such conversions will not be treated as payment u/s 43B for allowance of interest.
I fail to see the logic behind it. If assessee borrows from other lender to ACTUALLY pay the interest, the Revenue would not mind, I suppose, and should allow the deduction.
Fixed Deposits qualify for Deductions u/s 80C (xxi)
Provided such term deposit is not less than 5 years and is in a scheduled bank.
What if somebody prematurely encashes the term deposit. No provision for this exigency!
Associations, if specified u/s 90A, will transgress national sovereignty but with approval
This is a significant change ushering the tax regime to a truly multinational environment, where two transnational corporations can enter into a double taxation avoidance or relief treaty with approval of the Indian Government and get a preferential treatment of lower taxes under the IT Act of India.
What if a foreign specified entity is not empowered to enter into such agreement under the law of the country where it is resident! Or there is a dispute about taxability in the other country!
I would like to know whether such agreements will override tax treaties.
Long –Term Capital gains from transfer of Securities now subject to MAT u/s 115JB
Such Capital gains shall be treated as taxable income for the purpose of Section 115JB. Rate of tax u/s 115JB also has been increased from 7.5% to 10%.
Banks and Financial Institutions may be affected adversely by this provision.
IPOs now less Attractive
Investments in the eligible issues of equity shares was a good avenue for those assesses who earned long-term capital gains but could get away with the investment in eligible IPOs u/s 54ED. Now such investment opportunity will no more be available after March 31st, 2006.