News Update

Vinod Kumar, IRS, 2002 Batch, is no moreCabinet okays privatisation of 20 PSUs: PanagariyaIndian Industry required to move to global norms: KantDDA, DUSIB sign MoU to implement PMAY in DelhiFM inaurgurates CII Centre for Arbitration and MediationPM praises Cyprus for being 8th largest investor in India and invites Cypriots to invest in IndiaPay Commission recommendations on allowances - Lavasa panel propses modificationsCBDT signs 2 APAs relating to IT & Banking (See 'TII Brief' in TII)CBDT gives addl charge of Gujarat + Ahmedabad zones to P C Modi & Surat to Rajani K GuptaGovt to develop 100 more airports, says Jayant SinhaCentral Excise - Refunds - Passing on the incidence to the ultimate buyer - Supreme Court dismisses review petitionTariff Values of Gold, Silver and all Edible oils (except Crude Soya bean oil) reducedSimplification of tax regime to increase compliance: FMFM says no surprises likely in GST rate fixationKenyan Ambassador Karau appointed as New Chair of Agri PanelAbolition of FIPB to pave way for more FDI reforms: FMNo medical certificate required for PF withdrawal for illnessCX - Classification - Polyester Covered Yarn and Nylon Covered Yarn fall under CSH No. 5402.62/61: SCI-T - Seized material must have some nexus to additions sought to be made by AO and must be relevant for forming belief regarding escaped income: HCST - Reason that officials were involved in matters pertaining to challenge in some other matters, and, therefore, there has been delay in filing appeals is vague and cryptic: HCST For another field formation of same tax collection mechanism to take an alternative stand and, that too, for limited period of time is best described as 'tax opportunism': CESTATTrichy Customs seizes FC worth Rs 29 lakh from pax heading for MalaysiaFinance Secretary Panel submits report on allowances recommended by 7th Pay Panel; Now, Panel of Secretaries to examine itAamby Valley Reserve Price - Apex Court fixes at Rs 37392 CroreJharkhand is Third State to pass SGST law
 
Works Contract: The confusion continues

MARCH 20, 2017

By Pankaj Goel, CA

HISTORICALLY whenever the words 'Works Contract' appears before an indirect professional, he or she is always reminded of the intense litigations at the highest courts, the amendments in Constitution of India and resulting amendments in States and Central sales tax laws. The concept of works contract was settled only after the interpretations were given by the Apex Court and incorporated in the underlying provisions.

One of the basic deterrents for levying sales tax on works contracts before the amendment in Constitution was whether works contracts are goods or services. Thus, when under the impending GST, both services are goods are taxed, presumably there should not be such problem.

This article attempts to highlight one such issue that may again become the bone of contention for another round of litigation unless taken care of by the Government.

Revised GST Law (RGL) defines the term works contract as follows:

(110) "works contract" means a contract wherein transfer of property in goods is involved in the execution of such contract and includes contract for building, construction, fabrication, completion, erection, installation, fitting out, improvement, modification, repair, maintenance, renovation, alteration or commissioning of any immovable property

A bare perusal of the definition provides that works contract is divided into two parts:

1. It should be a contract wherein there should be transfer of property in goods;

2. It includes the list of contracts as mentioned in the definition.

It is also important to note Schedule II of the 'RGL' listing the transactions to be treated as goods or services. Entry 5 of the Schedule II defines certain transactions which will be treated as supply of services. Entry (f) is of interest to us, which reads as follows:

(f) works contract including transfer of property in goods (whether as goods or in some other form) involved in the execution of a works contract;

The said entry provides that all works contract will be treated as supply of services irrespective of fact whether there is transfer of property in goods involved or not in execution of such a works contract.

The necessary conclusion, which this article is trying to highlight, comes out of a conjoint reading of definition of works contract and Entry 5(f) of the Schedule II. As per the definition of works contract, any contract involving transfer of property in goods will be works contract. The term 'contract' needs to be interpreted in accordance with Indian Contract Act, 1872 which inturn provides that any legally enforceable agreement is a contract. Thus, an imperative inference, in the light of existing definition of works contract, is that all supplies involving transfer of property in goods will be treated as works contract. Thus, even the sales simplicitor can be treated as works contract. Furthermore, by virtue of Schedule II, such sales simplicitor transactions are nothing but the provision of services.

In other words for the sales simplicitor, the provisions relating to supply of services will be applicable and not that relating to supply of goods. Accordingly, it is imperative for the Government to take note of this anomaly and amend the definition of works contract probably in line with that existing under service tax as follows:

54) "works contract" means a contract wherein transfer of property in goods involved in the execution of such contract is leviable to tax as sale of goods and such contract is for the purpose of carrying out construction, erection, commissioning, installation, completion, fitting out, repair, maintenance, renovation, alteration of any movable or immovable property or for carrying out any other similar activity or a part thereof in relation to such property.

(The author is Partner, Apex Consultants and the views expressed are strictly personal)

(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and Taxindiaonline.com doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Taxindiaonline.com Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)

POST YOUR COMMENTS