Taxindiaonline.com Taxindiaonline.com Taxindiainternational.com HRindiaonline.com
 
LOGIN
Forgot Password |  Register
Saturday , February 28, 2015 | Updated : Feb 28, 14:53 IST
Income Tax    Customs    Excise    Service Tax    FEMA    DGFT    SEZ    Misc    Pitara    Budget   
About Us Contact Us Advertise
Taxindiaonline.com Taxindiaonline.com Taxindiainternational.com
BUDGET FLASH
 
'Substantial value' from assets located in India - when does Sec 9 get triggered? - Finance Bill provides an answer (See 'Budget Run-Up') Is proposed Section 78B of FA, 1994unconstitutional? (See 'Budget Run-Up') Duty not paid - Penalty follows in all cases, suppression or not (See 'Budget Run-Up') Place of Effective Management - Finance Bill proposes change to determine resident status (See 'Budget Run-Up') Interest paid by branch of foreign bank to HO and overseas branches chargeable to tax and subject to TDS Jaitley offers minor respite on depreciation u/s 32(iia)(See 'Budget Run-Up') GTA ST is on 30 % (See 'Budget Run-Up') Bye Bye to Education (CESSES)(See 'Budget Run-Up') Dead wood & something more removed from provisions of Settlement in Central Excise & Customs (See 'Budget Run-Up') Pleasant Amendment in Section 11AC (See 'Budget Run-Up') Section 80 of FA, 1994 to fade into oblivion - a draconian step? (See 'Budget Analysis') Mutual Fund distribution - Service tax makes a comeback (See 'Budget Analysis') Time to gear-up for GST (See 'Budget Analysis') Recovery of credit taken wrongly but not utilized is possible now - First accrued is first utilized - new Rule 14 of CCR, 2004 (See 'Budget Analysis') What happens to Education Cess credit lying in balance? (See 'Budget Analysis') Definition of Resident company redefined in Finance bill, 2015 (See 'Budget Analysis') Instant tea, Iced tea, LED lights/lamps brought under MRP assessment (See 'Budget Analysis') ST Valuation - If courts take a contrary view - Do the obvious - Amend the Act - Delhi High Court Ruling in Intercontinental Consultants undone (See 'Budget Analysis') Service tax exemption availed by non-resident Commission Agent to Indian exporter withdrawn (See 'Budget Analysis') Service tax exemption withdrawn for Mutual Fund Agent to MF; Distributor to MF or AMC; service by Lottery agent to distributor and also free telephone calls made by Airport and hospitals Litigation Management - Monetary Limit for case to be heard by Single ITAT Member hiked to Rs 15 lakh (See 'Budget Analysis') Service provided by Government brought under tax net Service Tax rate of 14% to be applicable only after enactment: education cess to continue till then Major changes proposed in Section 11 AC - No penalty for normal period cases if duty is paid along with interest within 30 days from Show Cause Notice Exclusion of value of rails - Retrospective exemption given Retrospective exemption granted to Railway or tramway track construction material Finance Bill - Cash seized to be adjusted towards assessee's tax liability Central Excise & Service Tax assessees allowed to issue digitally signed invoices Finance Bill cleans up provisions relating to Indirect Transfers under Section 9 of I-T Act MAT rationalised for members of AOP (Association of Persons) Rationalisation of Penal Provisions under Service Tax - Section 80 deleted No Change in Corporate Tax Rate for FY 2015-16 Chit funds and lottery to come under Service Tax Intaxicating - alcohol job work to attract Service tax Gold Monetisation Scheme: Depositors and jewellers to earn interest on metal account (See 'Mbuzz') Wealth tax gone but 2% surcharge levied on super rich; Medical allowance hiked to Rs 25000 (See 'Budget Analysis') Rental income from assets held by REITs to be taxed in hands of unit holders (See 'Budget Analysis') Foreign assets purchased out of tax evaded: 10 years jail; offence made non-compoundable and 300% penalty (See 'Budget Analysis') DTC Bill killed; Many good aspects incorporated in present I-T Act Service tax Negative List to be pruned No Service Tax on Varisth Bima Yojana Transport Allowance limit hiked to Rs 1600 Sec 80CCD benefit hiked by Rs 50,000 per annum Jaitley hikes exemption limit for medi claim from Rs 15K to 25K; for Sr Citizens it is to be 30K Clean Energy Cess hiked to Rs 200/- PMT; No service tax on effluent treatment plants Service tax rate goes up to 14% but education cess gone Excise duty on cigarette and tobacco hiked; Excise registration to be done in two working days; Cenvat Credit period extended from six months to 12 months TP threshold limit hiked from Rs 5 Crore to 20 Crore; Capital gains by FIIs not to be subjected to MAT Wealth Tax to be abolished; 2% surcharge levied on wealthy SAD removed for most goods with minor exception GAAR postponed for two years; Tax rate on royalty and FTS reduced to 10% Presence of Fund Managers not to be construed as PE Capital gains regime and STT regime to be rationalised to provide pass through facility Unreported assets outside India - Govt to make it predicate offence under PMLA Black Money Bill to be tabled - 10 years jail proposed; 300% penalty; No Settlement Commission option; No deductions to be allowed; even banks and companies to face prosecution and penalty Corporate tax rate to be reduced to 25% over four years Fiscal Deficit to be 3.9% in next fiscal HCs to have designated courts for resolution of Commercial disputes; Bill to be tabled Defence outlay hiked to Rs 2.46 lakh crore for 2015-16 Special Assistance like Telangana to be provided to Bihar, West Bengal also AIIMS to be set up in Punjab, Assam, J&K, HP, TN and Bihar + IIT in Karnataka + ISM Dhanbad becomes IIT + IIM to be set up in J & K Education Loan: Govt to set up formal platform to fund it Govt to launch National Skill Mission to enhance employability of youth Govt to go for Procurement Legislation; proposes mechanism to resolve contract disputes Govt to develop heritage sites to promote tourism FDI - Artificial distinction between FII & Portfolio Investment to go Govt to put in place New Direct Tax and Indirect Tax regime matching global standards Govt to introduce New Gold Monetisation Scheme; to introduce Indian Gold Coin with Ashok Chkra Govt to reform EPF and ESI Acts to make it more liberal Commodity Commission to be merged with SEBI Govt to set up Public Debt Management Agency to monitor borrowings Rs 5000 Cr allocated to National Infrastructure Development Fund Expert Panel to be set up to do away with prior-approval for starting business Govt earmarks Rs 1000 Cr to support tech start-ups FM allows tax-free bond option for road, rail and irrigation Investment in Infra Sector to go up by Rs 70,000 Crore; Govt to set up National Investment in Infrastructure; Govt to allocate Rs 20,000 Crore Unclaimed deposits of Rs 9000 Crore in PPF & EPF to be appropriated for Senior Citizen Welfare Fund NBFCs with Rs 500 Cr turnover to be construed as Financial Institution To improve Ease of Doing Business Index - Govt to go for New Bankruptcy Act
 
Bookmark and Share
Service Tax - Chit Funds not taxable under 'Banking and other financial services' - Board Circular quashed: AP High Court

By TIOL News Service

HYDERABAD, OCT 14, 2008 : IN the writ petitions, the petitioners sought for a mandamus and assailing the correctness of CBEC circular No. 96/7/2007-ST (Reference Code. 034-04) dated 23.8.2007 and proceedings No. HAST 141/2007 dated 18.12.2007 issued by the Commissioner as being violative of Article 14, 19 (1) (g) and 265 of the Constitution of India and Section 65 (12) read with section 65 (105) (zm) of the Finance Act, 1994 and to set aside the same.   The case of the petitioners is that they are doing business in chit funds, the transactions of which are clearly covered by the provisions of the A.P. Chit Funds Act, 1971 and the Rules made thereunder.  According to them, very nature of transaction stands quite apart.

The Board Circular may be seen for a clear understanding:

Services are provided in relation to chit funds. Chit Funds are of two types, namely :-

(a) Simple Chit Funds: In this case, members agree to contribute to the fund a certain amount at regular interval. Lots are drawn periodically and the member, whose name appears, gets the periodical collection. No separate amount is charged from the members.

(b) Business Chit Funds: In this case, there is a promoter known as foreman who draws up the terms and conditions of the scheme and enrolls subscribers. Every subscriber has to pay his subscription in regular installments. The foreman charges a separate amount for the services provided. Some States prescribe a ceiling limit for the amount to be charged by such promoter for the services provided. Commission amount is retained by the promoter as consideration for providing the services in relation to chit fund.

Whether services provided in relation to chit fund is leviable to service tax under “banking and other financial services” or not?

The Board’s clarification reads as,

Reserve Bank of India has clarified that the business of a chit fund is to mobilize cash from the subscribers and effectively cause movement of such cash to keep it working and, therefore, the activity of chit funds is in the nature of cash management.

(a) In the case of Simple Chit Funds, no consideration is paid or received for the services provided and, therefore, the question of levy of service tax does not arise.

(b) In the case of Business Chit Funds, cash management service is provided for a consideration and, therefore, leviable to service tax under “banking and other financial services”.

The petitioners made it clear to the Department that the very assumption by the respondents to treat the chit fund business to fall within the ambit of asset management is not correct nor valid in law and further pointed out that there is subtle difference between the banking and financial services as defined under the Act with that of the Chit transactions, therefore, no liability can be fastened on them.

Further it is pointed out that the Department cannot levy a tax for the first time on a totally new arena by issuance of a circular.  As long as the Finance Act is not properly modified or amended to bring within its fold the chit transactions, the demand made by the Department is totally unsustainable. 

It was further pointed out that even when the Budget proposals were made for 2007-08, the Hon’ble Finance Minister did not give any indication that the cash management would include the chit fund business and therefore it is neither the policy decision nor the law as enunciated at the relevant point of time to bring the chit fund business within the ambit of the asset management and thus the entire levy and demand is totally illegal, unconstitutional and as such liable to be set aside. 

The High Court observed,

It is not disputed that the taxing statute needs to be interpreted strictly.  It must be very specific about its levy rather than to import deeming interpretation.  The petitioners specifically raised a plea in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition that at the time of introduction of the service tax before 1994 or later when the Finance Act has undergone amendment and during the discussions of the Budget proposals, no indication was given by the Finance Minister to extend the provisions of service tax to the chit funds business.  There is no denial on this aspect nor there is any explanation.  Therefore, be it an asset management or cash management, both expressions strictly speaking did not find place in the definition clauses under any of the Finance Acts.  It does not include or exclude the chit transaction or business specifically.  There cannot be any dispute that the very nature of business and transaction under the chits as can be culled out from the provisions of the Chit Fund Act and it stands on its own as a class.  It does not have any parlance or similarity to that of normal transactions as one understood under the law or commercially.   Admittedly, there is no provision whatsoever by including specifically the chits within the meaning of either ‘cash management’ or ‘asset management’.  Therefore, irrespective of such amendment either by earlier inclusion or later exclusion of those expressions, it will not have bearing on the chit transaction.

The HC recalled the basic principles of taxation:

  • No tax can be imposed on the subject without words in the Act clearly showing an intention to lay a burden upon him.
  • The subject cannot be taxed unless he comes within the letter of the law; the argument that he falls within the spirit of the law cannot avail the Department.

  • Tax and equity are strangers and an equitable construction cannot be put upon the words of a taxing statute.
     
  • In a taxing Act one has to look merely at what is clearly said.  There is no room for any intendment.  There is no equity about a tax.  There is no presumption as to a tax.  Nothing is to be read in, nothing is to be implied.  One can only look fairly at the language used

Therefore in the absence of a specific statutory definition of ‘cash management’ or even ‘asset management’, the question of its wider interpretation either by seeking to include or exclude any other transactions or business does not arise and is not permissible and any such act on the part of the executive would certainly be in the teeth of Article 265 of the Constitution of India.  

The entire action on the part of the respondents in trying to extend the levy of the tax for the first time by way of a circular is merely an executive fiat, which is not permissible under the law.  

The impugned circular dated 23.8.2007 and consequential proceedings dated 18.12.2007 are set aside and accordingly the writ petitions are allowed.

(See 2008-TIOL-502-HC-AP-ST in 'Service Tax' + 2008-TIOL-502-HC-AP-ST in 'Legal Corner')


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   
 
 
Subscribe TIOL Tube Channel on YouTube
TIOL Mobile App
TIOL SEARCH
 
TIOL Subscriptions
 All-In-One Package
 Indirect Tax Package
 Income Tax Package
<< More Packages>>
 
   
             
Income Tax Customs Excise Service Tax FEMA DGFT SEZ Misc Pitara Budget
  • Notifications
  • Circulars
  • SC Cases
  • HC Cases
  • ITAT Cases
  • Instructions
  • Advance Ruling
  • Settlement
  • Other Case
  • Directorate of Income Tax (Systems)
  • Tariff Notfn
  • Non Tariff Notfn
  • Circulars
  • SC Cases
  • HC Cases
  • Cestat Cases
  • Settlement
  • Advance Ruling
  • Safeguard Duty Notfn
  • Anti-dumping Notfn
  • Drawback Cases
  • MISC Circulars
  • Tariff Notfn
  • Non Tariff Notfn
  • Circulars
  • SC Cases
  • HC Cases
  • Cestat Cases
  • Settlement
  • Advance Ruling
  • Excise Amendment
  • Clean Energy Cess Notfn
  • MISC Circulars
  • 37B Order
  • Commr.(A) Order
  • CESTAT
  • Notifications
  • Circulars
  • SC Cases
  • HC Cases
  • Cestat Cases
  • Miscellaneous
  • Advance Ruling
  • FAQ
  • Finance Act, 1994
  • Commr. (A) Orders
  • 37B Order
  • Removal of Difficulty
  • VCES
  • Accounting Head
  • Exchange Manual
  • Fema Notifications
  • SC Cases
  • HC Cases
  • RBI Notifications
  • Act
  • Rules
  • Regulations
  • Master Circulars
  • RBI Circulars
  • Depository Scheme
  • Press Note
  • Notifications
  • Circulars
  • Public Notices
  • Trade Notice
  • FTDR Amendment 2010
  • MISC
  • State Acts
  • Notifications
  • Instructions
  • Act 2005
  • Rules 2006
  • DGEP
  • State Policy
  • SC Cases
  • HC Cases
  • VAT Cases
  • Deputation Posts
  • Service News
  • The Insider
  • Transfer
  • Promotion
  • Recruitment Rules
  • Transfer Policy
  • Training Circulars
  • Service Cases
  • MISC
  • Pay Commission
  • Cadre Review
  • Budget Circular 2013-14
  • Union Budgets
  • Economic Surveys
  • Budget Speeches
  • Finance Acts
  • Finance Bill
  • TRU - D. O. Letter
  • A Taxindiaonline Website. Copyright © 2014 Taxindiaonline.com Pvt.Ltd. All rights reserved. | Powered by 4th Dimension