News Update

Sales Tax - 'sale price' apart from including consideration for sale, also includes value of any discount or rebate offered, which is to be deducted from sale price: SCGST - GoM on IT to review progress made by GSTN so far on SaturdayRailways inducts two digitally enabled LocomotivesADB loans USD 84 mn for improving water supply in Bhagalpur & GayaIAS Association delegation meets Dr Jitendra SinghFodder scam - Laloo pleads for bail; Jharkhand HC says NOIES officers to get new houses soonIndia successfully testifires N-capable ballistic missile ‘Dhanush’ from Naval Ship off Orissa coastIndian, Canadian PMs resolve to expedite BIPA & CEPA pactsCBDT notifies India-Kenya DTAA (See 'http://www.taxindiainternational.com/')GST on 'Commission' Received in Convertible Foreign Exchange – Part-I (See 'TOG Insight' in Taxongo.com)Electoral Bond Scheme to open on Mar 1 for 10 daysNDMA organises workshop on action plan to deal with heat waveRailways organises suppliers' Samvad; Digital Challan launchedChanges in the business connection provision (See 'Edit' in 'taxindiainternational.com')I-T - Department has no right to re-examine entire issue from a different angle, if returned income of assessee is accepted barring minor adjustment of expenditure claim: HCGST Council meeting - pointers from Industry for considerationCus - CBLR, 2013 - Prohibition - Even orders passed under Regulation 23 are appealable u/s 129A of CA, 1962: HCCertain grey areas in Taxability of 'Bill to - Ship to' TransactionsST - Refund - Banking services and technical inspection & certification services are co-related with export; are Input services: HCGovt notifies Electoral Bonds; Political parties can encash bonds only through bankBig relief for Indian students joining MBBS abroad; Govt grants them exemption from qualifying NEETFinance Commission invites inputs for widening of tax baseCanada to aid India in research effortsCivil Services Day - Four priority programmes listed for PM's AwardsI-T - When assessee diverted sum received for procuring import licences for purchase of shares, such advance is to be construed as deemed dividend u/s 2(22)(e): HCI-T - If Revenue initiates penalty proceedings after six months of receipt of adjudicatory order, such proceeding is beyond period of limitation imposed u/s 275: HCGST Council to meet on March 10 through video conferencing; likely to approve new GSTR design and many amendment in GST lawsPNB fraud - ED & Income Tax continue to seize luxury vehicles & assets of Nirav Modi & ChoksiBank Frauds - Taxpayers tired to pay for 'New Civilisation'!I-T - It is clear case of barking up wrong tree if Revenue records show no tax arrears against assessee: HCIntermediary services to foreign parties-inter-state or intra-state supply?
 
CX - Dismissal of appeal on sole ground that adjudication of lis involving minor demand would not be productive is failure to exercise jurisdiction: HC

By TIOL News Service

CHENNAI, DEC 07, 2017: THE CESTAT, Chennai passed the following Final order dated 3/1/2017-

"Appeal pertains to duty demand of Rs.7,42,297/-. We do not consider it productive in this appeal to invest time by the Tribunal while there is huge pendency involving crores of rupees of Revenue. Therefore, appeal with a very minor demand of duty levied is dismissed."

The aforesaid order is assailed on the following substantial questions of law:-

a. Whether the second respondent is right in depriving the appellant the statutory right as provided under Section 35 (c) of the Central Excise Act, 1944?

b. Whether the second respondent is right in dismissing the appeal filed by the appellant by issuing an order mentioning that they do not consider it productive to invest time by the Tribunal while there is huge pendency involving crores of rupees and revenue and therefore, this appeal with minor demand of duty levied?

The appellant invited the attention of the Court to its decision in Roots Multiclean Ltd. =  2016-TIOL-324-HC-MAD-CX .

The High Court noted that on more than one occasion, the Supreme Court has held that reasons are the heartbeat of any decision and dismissal of the appeal without adverting to the facts, grounds of appeal is not appreciated [M/s.Steel Authority of India Ltd., v. STO, Rourkela-I Circle & Ors. =  2008-TIOL-133-SC-CT, Kranti Associates Private Limited and another vs Masood Ahamed Khan and Others) (2010) 9 SCC 496 relied upon].

The High Court further observed -

"9. Dismissal of the appeal, on the sole ground that there is a huge pendency involving crores of rupees of revenue and adjudication of lis involving a minor demand of duty of Rs.7,42,297/- would not be productive, in our opinion is a failure to exercise the jurisdiction conferred on CESTAT, Madras, both on facts and law. In terms of Section 35B of the Central Excise Act, the appellant is certainly an aggrieved person by the orders impugned before CESTAT, Madras."

The Civil Miscellaneous appeal was allowed by setting aside the Final order of the CESTAT. Substantial questions of law were answered in favour of the assessee.

Noting that the appeal was filed by the assessee in the year 2007, the Tribunal was directed to dispose of the same expeditiously within a period of two months.

(See 2017-TIOL-2523-HC-MAD-CX)


POST YOUR COMMENTS