News Update

IAS Association condemns attack on Delhi Chief Secretary; demands immediate actionICAI removes name of O P Tulsyan from register of Members for five years in compliance with Allahabad HC orderST - Supreme Court agrees with Larger Bench CESTAT decision in Bhayana Builders - Revenue appeals dismissedCabinet clears bills on illicit deposit & chit funds regulations (See 'TIOLCorplaws')Cabinet nod for Tribunal on river disputeCabinet nod for bus bay near Indian Defence UniversityCabinet nod for coal mining methodologyCabinet okays Indo-Moroccan railway pactFive IRS officers appointed as CESTAT Members - Sanjiv Srivastava (Mumbai) + P Anjani Kr (Mumbai) + P Venkata Subba Rao (Hyderabad) + Bijay Kr (Delhi) + C L Mahar (Delhi)CBDT issues transfer order of four CITsI-T - Incriminating evidences obtained prior to date of search, cannot be roped in to make additions in case of unabated assessments: ITATPNB scam should pave road for financial transparencyBurdensome registration requirement under GST law be done away withST World Bank and International Finance Corporation are part of United Nations, therefore, there is no need to resort to definition of International Organization for extending benefit of notification 16/2002-ST: CESTATAnti Profiteering Application - An analysisCX - Merely on basis of statement given by one employee to police that raw materials worth Rs.2 crore were destroyed in fire, same cannot be taken as gospel truth: CESTATGovt keen to make agri schemes 'income-centric' rather than 'production-centric': MinisterKolkata DRI seizes 12.4 kg elephant tusk being smuggled from Assam to NepalDigital India successing becoz of people's pull: PMFish eats plastic & humans eat fish - serious health hazard: MinisterI-T - When assessee was only a licensee, not having exclusive rights over a property, vide unregistered document, it cannot claim to be owner of property for purpose of Sec 22: HCRailways relaxes upper age limit for Group C postsNo GST is leviable on goods sold/transferred while remaining in Customs bonded warehouseLeviability of IGST and as well as Compensation cess under Customs ActAG expresses concern over CBEC cases being dismissed by SC on ground of delayTime to shift focus from acronyms to gaps in performanceGST - Industry reports cumbersome procedures & high cost of compliance
GST is here - Enjoy the inevitable

JULY 01, 2017

By Vijay K Kumar

Legal Corner IconNow there is no point in complaining that the Laws are confusing, that the Government is not ready, that the taxpayer is not ready, that there is going to be chaos all around. Now GST is here for real – we have no choice but to enjoy the inevitable.

We started our column "ST se GST Tak" in August 2007 with a hope that GST would come in a couple of years. But it took almost ten years to reach the "tak". The great officer who started the column for us and who we thought would be the sole author to take us through ST to GST stopped writing after a few weeks. Unfortunately, he is not with us at this historic moment.

Launching the GST at midnight, the Prime Minister who has a penchant for finding new meanings, in more senses than one, said it is a Good and Simple Tax, while many would condemn it as a Goddamned Satanic Tax. In the Good and Simple Tax, there is certainly more of tax and very little of good and simple . But the Indian taxpayer has always been a silent victim of tax terrorism unleashed by the State. The number of Tax cases pending in our Tribunals and Courts, is a monumental proof to this.

In this strange "One Tax, One Nation", we have some half a dozen taxes and the legislative weight on our heads is mind boggling. In the last count, I found that we have

1 Constitution Amendment Act

4 Acts

16 Rules

117 formats

73 Notifications (some of them already amended, even before the GST has come into force)

1 Circular.

From 0000 hours of today, every Taxpayer, rather every Indian is assumed to be fully aware of all the above pristine legislative provisions, for as they say, 'ignorance of Law is no excuse', especially on the part of taxpayers. Tax officers, lawyers and judges are exempted.

Distinguished readers of TIOL are aware of the Infinite Monkey Theorem which goes something like this.

A monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard for an infinite amount of time will almost surely type or create a particular chosen text, such as the complete works of William Shakespeare .

Suppose the typewriter has 50 keys, and the phrase to be typed is 'one tax'. If the keys are pressed randomly and independently, it means that each key has an equal chance of being pressed. Then, the chance that the first letter typed is 'o' is 1/50, and the chance that the second letter typed is ‘n’ is also 1/50, and so on. Therefore, the chance of the first six letters spelling 'one tax' is

(1/50) × (1/50) × (1/50) × (1/50) × (1/50) × (1/50) = 1/1562,50,00,000, less than one in 15 billion, but not zero, hence a possible outcome.

From the above, the chance of not typing 'onetax' in a given block of 6 letters is 1 - 1/1562,50,00,000. Because each block is typed independently, the chance Xn of not typing ‘onetax’ in any of the first n blocks of 6 letters is

Am I trying to confuse you with a mathematical formula? Then read this 39(d) Rule of the GST Input Tax Credit Rules

(d) the input tax credit that is required to be distributed in accordance with the provisions of clause (d) and (e) of sub-section (2) of section 20 to one of the recipients 'R1', whether registered or not, from amongst the total of all the recipients to whom input tax credit is attributable, including the recipient(s) who are engaged in making exempt supply, or are otherwise not registered for any reason, shall be the amount, "C1", to be calculated by applying the following formula: -

C1=(t T) X C


"C" is the amount of credit to be distributed,

"t1" is the turnover, as referred to in section 20, of person R1 during the relevant

period, and

"T" is the aggregate of the turnover, during the relevant period, of all recipients to whom the input service is attributable in accordance with the provisions ofsection 20,;

A Good and Simple Tax indeed!

I am not complaining. If the Prime Minister says it is a Good and Simple Tax, who am I to say otherwise?

The Finance Minister said in Parliament, "if you said that a Hawaii chappal and a BMW car have one rate, then it will be a regressive tax. That is not possible." Fine, but now Gold is taxed at 3 percent while spectacles are charged at 12% and last night, the Prime Minister mentioned that the inconvenience with GST would be something akin to the slight difficulty with a pair of new spectacles.

Alright, now is not the time for ruminating on how nice it would have been if the tax was postponed by just a month, if the GSTN was really ready, if the laws were a little simple .. and so on. This is not the time to stand and stare; this is the time to do or die. We have to live with GST and as it is inevitable, why not enjoy it? Yours is not to question why; yours is but to comply.

As a nation, we get the tax we deserve and anyway as God runs this country, if there’s a problem, He will fix it, somehow. And if you don’t believe in God, soon you will.

The Prime Minister said GST is a collective effort – you can’t blame anyone individually. All the decisions of the GST Council have been unanimous

Before a medicine is launched, they usually test it on rats and rabbits, but perhaps no such facility exists or is legally required before a tax is imposed. Unfortunately, unlike the bitter pill, you have no choice with taxation of refusing to swallow.

Now that GST is in force, I hope the tax officers will read (and perhaps understand) all the above simple laws, before they embark upon enforcing them. I fervently hope that all the experts and consultants will read and understand those laws before they advise and preach on GST. As of now, we may also seek the help of astrologers, vaasthu experts and godmen.

We had to struggle to keep our column ‘ST se GST Tak’ afloat for ten years, but I have absolutely no doubt about continuing the column with the title, "In GST’s Times". Does that sound like Injustice Times?

Into that GST world, let us march confidently. All the best.


GST Rollout - Are We Ready? - Episode 2 (Concluded)

GST Roll-Out - Are we ready? - Episode 1

GST Rollout | Episode 2 | simply inTAXicating

GST Rollout | simply inTAXicating

Also See : TIOL TUBE Videos on GST


(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)


Sub: enjoy the inevitable

The writeup though small stands out as one of the best. I honestly fell in love with the sentences 'ignorance of Law is no excuse', especially on the part of taxpayers. Tax officers, lawyers and judges are exempted.

Posted by sujisham sham