News Update

Kolkata DRI seizes 12.4 kg elephant tusk being smuggled from Assam to NepalDigital India successing becoz of people's pull: PMFish eats plastic & humans eat fish - serious health hazard: MinisterI-T - When assessee was only a licensee, not having exclusive rights over a property, vide unregistered document, it cannot claim to be owner of property for purpose of Sec 22: HCRailways relaxes upper age limit for Group C postsIndia to create digital health platform for better service delivery: NaddaST/CX - No vested right exists to avail benefit of unutilized amount of EC or SHE credit - Article 14 is not offended - Petition dismissed: HCIndian delegation promotes cinema in European Film MarketNo GST is leviable on goods sold/transferred while remaining in Customs bonded warehouseI-T - If assessee-society enters into contract with State Govt to cook & supply mid-day meals at schools, such activity is not necessarily in nature of trade and business: HCLeviability of IGST and as well as Compensation cess under Customs ActCX - CENVAT -Since Respondent's factory occupied 95% of factory area, they are entitled for 95% of total CENVAT credit on common input services: CESTATTripura elections - 75% voter turnout recordedIndia has potential to do much better, says FM in RiyadhIranian Plane Crash - 66 pax feared killedAG expresses concern over CBEC cases being dismissed by SC on ground of delayTime to shift focus from acronyms to gaps in performanceGST - Industry reports cumbersome procedures & high cost of complianceFICCI Survey finds compression in cost of funds indexDomestic air travel registers 20% growth in January, 2018Globalisation Index - India loses 16 places to rank 78India, Iran sign MoU to set up Expert Group on Trade Remedy MeasuresIndia to launch Chandrayaan-2 in AprilGST - Many States want GST Council to discuss inclusion of real estate at next meetingSeaports located at Dhamra Port and Dighi Port included for availing export promotion benefits under Chapter 4 of FTPGovt working on formulation of National Automotive PolicyCBEC accepts 63 Court Orders to reduce litigationTax Season Has Started, Here's Your To-Do List for This SeasonGST: Death of the Salesman?
Piecemeal initiatives like Demonetisation can't kill black money & bribery

NOVEMBER 11, 2016

By TIOL Edit Team

THE Government's decision to demonetise Rs. 500 and Rs 1000 notes has evoked mixed reactions - very strong support from some quarters and muted to cynical criticism from others.

The trade-off between the benefits of so-called surgical strikes on black money and collateral damage to law-abiding citizens is hard to gauge. Reckon the collateral damage as colossal time loss inflicted on the masses and acute discomfort to persons in tight situations such as making payments to private hospitals and chemists and organizing solemn events such as marriages. Factor in temporary disruption in economic activities that are largely cash driven.

Demonetisation is thus like chemotherapy that harms not only cancerous cells but all cells that are essential to sustain life in a human being. And as often happens in such treatment, supposedly eradicated cancerous cells return to harm the body (read economy) with vengeance after a few years. Black money and its cousin corruption are cancers of the worst sort.

The fact is that demonetization puts whole economy and society to great deal of inconvenience just for the sake of punishing a section of holders of black money. Demonetisation affects only those who did not convert their black money into bullion and diamonds, real estate and other expensive assets.

"Demonetisation curbs the white economy and will also curb the black economy in a credit constrained regime," concluded a working paper titled 'Aggregate Demand with Parallel Markets' published by National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP) in 1989.

It is perhaps because of this conviction that successive governments including Vajpayee Government avoided the soft option of demonetization. It is certainly soft as compared to organizing frequent searches and seizures at premises of suspected black money operators/tax evaders/bribe takers; regular surveillance of ministers and officials at bribery-prone jobs, shedding all discretionary powers and ordering double audit of sensitive transactions and giving full autonomy to enforcement agencies including Lok Pal, which remains unborn after about 40 years of labour. Don't forget other hard options for rulers- introducing simple, stable and durable tax regime and reducing controls to a bare minimum.

If the country's experience with previous two instances of demonetisation of high denomination notes - 1st in 1946 & 2nd in 1978, the amount of black money eradicated this time might also be small.

It is here pertinent to quote Finance Ministry-commissioned 1985 study on black money. Captioned 'Aspects of the Black Economy in India', the study by National Institute of Public Finance and Policy (NIPFP), stated: "crude index of the penal success of this measure is given by the value of high denomination notes which were not presented for conversion. By this yardstick, neither venture was success."

The study added: "Quite apart from the relatively paltry results obtained on the two occasions on which it has been tried, there are other good reasons to doubt the efficacy of this measure in combating black income generation."

The reasons are: 1) The measure is limited to inflicting penalties on those who hold their black wealth in the form of cash at the moment of demonetisation. 2) Second, even for holders of cash, there exist avenues for converting high denomination notes into lower valued ones, at discount, through intermediaries. 3) Demonetisation does not strike at various root causes of generation of black money. 4) It disturbs only temporarily the black economy and serves an opportunity for black economy stakeholders to be on guard in future.

We can safely assume that these four factors have not been disputed by three black money studies commissioned by UPA Government and tightly kept under the carpet by NDA Government. In any case, cannons of good governance require the Government to make public three studies submitted by NIPFP, National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER) and National Institute of Financial Management (NIFM) more than a couple of years back.

Public expects Modi Government to crack the whip on politicians and top officials who largely avoid black money net by engineering a web of cashless corrupt practices. These can be in the form of quid pro quo deals with favoured corporate houses.

Such deals run into several crore of rupees. They take the form of equity investments, consultancy fees and corporate social responsibility donations to entities controlled by persons close to favour-dispensing ministers and officials. Some of these benefiting entities are registered abroad including tax havens.

This brings us to larger issue of Government's reluctance to unveil a comprehensive strategy to fight twin and related evils of black money and corruption.

In the absence of multi-facet and integrated approach to rooting out corruption and black money, piecemeal and easy options like amnesty schemes for tax evaders and demonetisation would leave these evils to survive and hit back like antibiotics-resistant pathogens.

Also See : TIOL TUBE Videos on Black Money Saga

Simply inTAXicating - Black Money Saga



Making & Faking Of Indian Rupee- Episode 1

Making & Faking Of Indian Rupee- Episode 2

Also See : TIOL TUBE Videos on BLACK MONEY

Black Money Bill