News Update

Kolkata DRI seizes 12.4 kg elephant tusk being smuggled from Assam to NepalDigital India successing becoz of people's pull: PMFish eats plastic & humans eat fish - serious health hazard: MinisterI-T - When assessee was only a licensee, not having exclusive rights over a property, vide unregistered document, it cannot claim to be owner of property for purpose of Sec 22: HCRailways relaxes upper age limit for Group C postsIndia to create digital health platform for better service delivery: NaddaST/CX - No vested right exists to avail benefit of unutilized amount of EC or SHE credit - Article 14 is not offended - Petition dismissed: HCIndian delegation promotes cinema in European Film MarketNo GST is leviable on goods sold/transferred while remaining in Customs bonded warehouseI-T - If assessee-society enters into contract with State Govt to cook & supply mid-day meals at schools, such activity is not necessarily in nature of trade and business: HCLeviability of IGST and as well as Compensation cess under Customs ActCX - CENVAT -Since Respondent's factory occupied 95% of factory area, they are entitled for 95% of total CENVAT credit on common input services: CESTATTripura elections - 75% voter turnout recordedIndia has potential to do much better, says FM in RiyadhIranian Plane Crash - 66 pax feared killedAG expresses concern over CBEC cases being dismissed by SC on ground of delayTime to shift focus from acronyms to gaps in performanceGST - Industry reports cumbersome procedures & high cost of complianceFICCI Survey finds compression in cost of funds indexDomestic air travel registers 20% growth in January, 2018Globalisation Index - India loses 16 places to rank 78India, Iran sign MoU to set up Expert Group on Trade Remedy MeasuresIndia to launch Chandrayaan-2 in AprilGST - Many States want GST Council to discuss inclusion of real estate at next meetingSeaports located at Dhamra Port and Dighi Port included for availing export promotion benefits under Chapter 4 of FTPGovt working on formulation of National Automotive PolicyCBEC accepts 63 Court Orders to reduce litigationTax Season Has Started, Here's Your To-Do List for This SeasonGST: Death of the Salesman?
 
Substitute piecemeal approach with a composite one to fuel growth

JANUARY 08, 2016

By TIOL Edit Team

"Put every small ticket together and you get a big-ticket reform: Nirmala Sitharaman". This headline for a year-end interview that the Commerce and Industry Minister gave to the Economic Times is a pithy comment on the process of Indian reforms.

Big-ticket reforms require political spine, which most parties lack even when empowered with a clear-cut mandate. We might agree that the country can do without or delay big-ticket reforms. We, however, feel pained to see the country suffering since the Independence for want of holistic reforms across all walks of life.

Successive ruling alliances have relied on piecemeal approach to reforms that are neither synergetic in effect nor holistic in impact. This is the story of reforms across almost all the sectors with several of them waiting for new policies or full implementation of government decisions for many years.

The management of reforms process is as good or as bad under the national democratic alliance (NDA) as it was under United Progressive Alliance (UPA). The other day social reformer Anna Hazare also noted that "There is no visible difference" between the two regimes.

We can drive home the issue of piecemeal reforms by looking at NDA's two latest announcements on the public sector front.

On 6th January, Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) approved closure of three subsidiaries of HMT Limited. It also cleared cash assistance of Rs. 427.48 crore to these firms to enable them to offer "attractive" golden handshake to about 1000 employees, who have remained on the rolls in spite of voluntary retirement packages given over the years.

As put by an official release, "The movable and immovable assets of the companies will be disposed of as per the Govt. policy."

A proper and adequate disclosure on this issue would have been welcome as HMT is sitting on huge chunks of land measuring 3035 acres. As land is the scarcest resource and a major constraint in expediting economic growth & jobs creation, the Government ought to lay clear-cut policy on productive use of public sector land.

The importance of this aspect can be appreciated by looking at the market value and vantage location of the surplus or idle land on which totally unviable public enterprises are either gasping for survival or lying closed.

In May this year, a news report quoted Anant Geete, Minister of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises, as saying that the Government would mop up Rs 22,000 crore from sale of assets of five PSUs including three HMT subsidiaries.

Has fiscally-constrained Government, which is faced with slowdown prospects, cared to formulate a time-bound initiative to put to efficient use its idling assets?

This brings us to the need for a comprehensive policy on public sector and utilization of its assets for 'Make in India', 'Skill India and 'Digital India' programmes.

The fourteenth Finance Commission (TFC), in its report submitted in February 2015, recommended that the Government should "shape and develop a comprehensive public sector enterprise policy with adequate focus on the fiscal costs and benefits." It has in fact given a complete package of suggestions on public sector.

The Finance Ministry has conveniently overlooked this fact the other day while invoking TFC to rationalize its decision to coax public enterprises to dole out uniformly 30% dividend to the Government. The decision has been articulated as enunciation of a clear-cut dividend policy.

In its office memorandum dated 5th January, the Ministry says: "The Fourteenth Finance Commission (FFC) had remarked that unlike operational matters in which the Board and management should have autonomy, transfer to reserves and payment of dividends is a policy matter which the Government, as owners, should decide. According to FFC, the dividends policy should cater to the requirements of the Government also, as it would in case of any prudent investor/ owner. This is especially true in times of current fiscal crunch."

It is high time the Government frames a comprehensive public sector policy taking into account package of recommendations made by FFC and earlier commissions. The Government can factor in relevant suggestions made by other official bodies.

Productive utilization of assets including cash and land in the entire Government domain is the surefire way to putting the economy on robust and sustainable growth track.

And to do this, Modi Government does not require any legislative action. It can't thus blame the Opposition as it had done so for delay in enacting GST law due to Parliament logjam. The Government must realize that it is sitting on goldmine of assets, whose utilization can unleash an impact that would be many times higher than what is hyped about GST.


POST YOUR COMMENTS