News Update

I-T - High Court need not intervene in matter involving factual issues; petitioner may utilise option of appeal: HCChina asks Blinken to select between cooperation or confrontationI-T - Unexplained cash credit - additions u/s 68 unsustainable where based on conjecture & surmise alone: ITATHonda to set up USD 11 bn EV plant in CanadaI-T - Re-assessment is invalid where based only on a suspicion that income escaped assessment & where not based on concrete reasons to believe for commencing such proceedings : ITATImran Khan banned from flaying State InstitutionsI-T - Income from sale of flats cannot be computed in assessee's hands, where legal possession of flats had not been handed over to buyers in that particular AY: ITATPro-Palestine demonstration spreads across US universities; 100 arrestedI-T - Investment activities in venture capital which are not covered in negative list under Schedule III to SEBI Regulations, qualifies for deduction u/s 10(23FB): ITATNATO asks China to stop backing Russia if keen to forge close ties with WestCus - When Department has not complied with time limit, the order issued for revocation of licence or order issued for continuation of suspension licence cannot sustain: CESTATNY top court quashes conviction of Harvey Weinstein in rape caseWeather prediction normal for phase 2 poll dayIndiGo orders 30 Airbus A350s for long haulsST - Appellant is an 'authorised medical practitioner' providing 'healthcare services' - services exempted in terms of clause 2(i) of notification 25/2012-ST: Commr(A)RBI to issue fresh guidelines for banks to freeze suspected bank accounts being used for cyber crimesREC avails SACE-Covered Green Loan for 60.5 Billion Japanese YenStudy finds Coca-Cola accounts for 11% of branded plastic pollution worldwideCus - 'Small Form-factor Pluggable Optical Transceivers' are classifiable under CTH 8517 7090 and not under CTH 8517 62 90 - entitled for benefit of duty concession under 57/2017-Cus: CESTATDoNER discusses Development of Tourism in North EastCX - Appellant is eligible for exemption under Notfn 12/2012-CE upon fulfilling all conditions stipulated therein, thus sufficiently establishing that goods dealt with by Appellants qualify for exemption: CESTAT
 
Judging a Judge’s Poetry - Review of ‘New Frontiers'

Dr. SL Peeran, Member CESTAT is an acclaimed poet, having to his credit six published volumes. We have Dr Sreekumar Menon, Commissioner, Customs and Central Excise another acclaimed poet reviewing Dr Peeran's latest book, "New Frontiers".

 

New Frontiers!
Judging a Judge’s Poetry
Review of ‘New Frontiers' (Poem)
by
Dr. G. Sreekumar Menon,
Commissioner of Customs & Excise

Poetry writing judges are very rare, for constraints of time and temperament inhibit many from pursuing literary pleasures. But, occasionally when we bump into a poetry writing judge, he elicits our admiration and accolades. Dr. S.L. Peeran, Member CESTAT, Bangalore belongs to the rare tribe of poetry writing judges. His latest poetic creation ‘New Frontiers’ is before me for a review. After traversing the 100 odd pages, I feel Dr. S.L. Peeran sitting directly opposite me and declaring

“But mind you, Sir, I am steadfast
Truthful to the hilt; simpleton
Sans show, pomposity, gibberish
Mindful of my business and my work”


Those who know Dr..Peeran will appreciate that the above self introduction is apposite and calls for no correction. In case you have misread him, he volunteers a further clarification :

“No, he isn’t a crazy man or ill
He is too Conscious and sane
He is on a high intellectual plane
With a broad prophetic vision”


But, why a prophetic vision? Because :

“Only a prophet can shake
you from slumber”

                          (Let Them Sleep)

And what does the prophet tell ?

“Over indulgence in the pleasures of the body and in organs of procreation
Disturbs the rhythm of sleep and rest
Dancing to the tunes of mirth and joys”

                                                   (Betray Yourself)

Pathetic desperation of the poet seeing the world abounding with cheats and crooks.

“The Corridors of power are thrown open
To marauders, plunderers and thugs”

                                                 (Betray Yourself)

And what is the recipe for their success ?

“By being sly, secretive towards one and all
just to remain in power
Position, fame, by hook or crook”
                                              (A Knave)

And if you cannot be like that, then :

“Your career and reputation damaged beyond repair
Your heart bleeding and your body becoming deed wood”

                                                (Dead Wood)

The poet is grief stricken that every body misunderstands him :

“His actions were all the more defensive
Than to cause hurt or offence
But the timings of his acts were such
That he was pronounced “guilty” by all”.

                                                (Haste Makes Waste)

Passages like the above abound in this collection. There is an auto biographical element strewn all over. And when he is not in an autobiographical mood, he is sermonising, moralising and preaching to a generation that is uncomfortable with such a line of thinking. Dr. S.L. Peeran himself is fully aware of this, and his self confession is revealing :

“You are an odd man in the lot
who should have lived in some bygone era”

                                                      (our Capital City)

The poems are full of candid confessions, sentimental outpourings and self appraisal of a wronged man thrown amidst wrong people.

Dr. G. Sreekumar Menon
Commissioner of Customs & Excise


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri N K Singh, recipient of TIOL FISCAL HERITAGE AWARD 2023, delivering his acceptance speech at Fiscal Awards event held on April 6, 2024 at Taj Mahal Hotel, New Delhi.


Shri Ram Nath Kovind, Hon'ble 14th President of India, addressing the gathering at TIOL Special Awards event.