CENTRAL EXCISE SECTION
2008-TIOL-1203-CESTAT-DEL-LB.pdf + amritlala story.pdf
Amrit Bottlers Pvt Ltd Vs CCE, Allahabad (Dated: June 2, 2008)
Draining
out aerated waters – President feels there is conflict between two orders and refers the matter to Larger Bench; no
conflict holds LB; there is no conflict between the decision
in the case of Amrit Bottlers and Hindustan C oca C ola beverages.
Both the decisions are on different facts of the case. In these
circumstances matter is referred to the referral bench to decide
the issue on merit. : DELHI CESTAT; 2008-TIOL-1202-CESTAT-KOL.pdf + tata story.pdf
M/s Tata Steel Ltd Vs CCE, Jamshedpur (Dated: June 24, 2008)
"Integrated steel plant" means
a manufacturer or a producer who, starting from the stage of
iron ore, manufactures or produces within the same premises the
excisable goods specified Chapter 72 or Chapter 73 - Board's
Circular No.696/12/2003-CX, dated 26.02.2003, clarifies that
the word 'ore' also includes ore concentrate - Clarification
seeks to clarify the legal position as it existed from the date
of issue of the notification benefit available to appellants
It is also common knowledge and a fact of history that TISCO is the first integrated steel plant which was set up in India even prior to independence as a shining example of a pioneer nationalist entrepreneur's efforts when steel was being imported from abroad despite our country having rich sources of iron ore (Para 6)
The Appellants have also argued that a subsequent show cause notice dated 23.02.06 issued by the same Commissioner takes a contrary stand that ore concentrate is not a different commercial commodity and on that ground, a huge demand has been raised against the Appellants alleging irregular availment of CENVAT Credit. Confirmation of the present demand and raising of the subsequent demand clearly indicate a state of confusion in which the Excise Authorities are working (Para 8)
We are somewhat concerned that the Commissioner who is having jurisdiction over an integrated steel plant, goes on to confirm a huge demand of duty and penalty of over Rs. 235 crores on the sole ground that M/s. TISCO is not an integrated steel plant. He also disregards a specific circular issued by the Board to clarify that ore includes ore concentrate. Before confirming such a huge demand and disregarding a specific circular issued by the Board, it was advisable for the Commissioner to consult the Board and also to verify the position in respect of the other integrated steel plants, some of which are not located far from the Adjudicating Commissioner's jurisdiction. There does not seem to be any record that such an exercise has been done. There was a time when the training of an I.R.S. (Customs and Central Excise) Officer was not considered complete unless he was familiar with the manufacturing and excise system of an integrated steel plant and an integrated textile mill : KOLKATA CESTAT;
2008-TIOL-1201-CESTAT-MAD.pdf
M/s Madan Agro Industries (India) Ltd Vs CCE, Salem (Dated: May 13, 2008)
Central
Excise – demand of duty on coconut oil as hair oil under Tariff item 33059019 – classification of the goods under heading 1513 is supported by the Board Circular and also by the orders of the Tribunal – prima
facie case made out for waiver of pre-deposit. : CHENNAI CESTAT;
SERVICE TAX SECTION
2008-TIOL-1199-CESTAT-MUM.pdf + stgst.pdf
Force Motors Ltd Vs CCE, Pune (Dated: July 11, 2008)
In
the current jet age, use of company owned and operated Aircraft
is a bare requisite for business activities – Service Tax charged
by Airports Authority of India for parking the aircraft at the
Airport is entitled for Cenvat Credit as Input Service
Tribunal
decision in Indian Rayon & Industries Ltd. [ 2006-TIOL-1152-CESTAT-MUM ] relied upon. : MUMBAI CESTAT; 2008-TIOL-1198-CESTAT-MAD.pdf
M/s Fifth Avenue Vs CST, Chennai (Dated: March 25, 2008)
Service
Tax – Stay/Dispensation of pre-deposit – Business Auxiliary Service Vs Business Support Service – the elements of services rendered by the appellants are found in Business Support Service – Pre-deposit
waived. : CHENNAI CESTAT; CUSTOMS SECTION
NOTIFICATION
dgft08cir023.pdf
Eligibility
of supplies to EOUs for deemed export benefits;
dgft08pn054.pdf
Agency
designated for export of sugar to USA;
cnt08_098.pdf CBEC notifies Customs exchange rates for August;
CASE LAWS 2008-TIOL-1200-CESTAT-MAD.pdf
M/s Pushpanjali Silk Pvt Ltd Vs CC, Chennai (Dated: May 1, 2008) Customs – valuation of mulberry raw silk of Chinese origin – enhancement of value based on contemporaneous Bills of entry – the appellant was not supplied with the copies of the said Bills of Entry – principles of natural justice violated – no
infirmity in the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) in remanding
the case for a fresh decision. : CHENNAI CESTAT; |