CENTRAL
EXCISE SECTION
2007-TIOL-775-CESTAT-MUM-LB.doc
+
lb story.doc
Slitting
and cutting of duty paid plastic laminated films into smaller rolls
does not amount to manufacture under S.2(f) of the CEA'44 - Larger
Bench of Tribunal - SC decision in S.R.Tissues [2005-TIOL-101-SC-CX]
& Delhi High Court decision in Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders
Association [2003-TIOL-79-HC-DEL-CX]
relied upon.
Apex
Court decisions in Indian Aluminium Cable & Laminated Packings
[2002-TIOL-285-SC-CX]
are distinguishable inasmuch as in the case of Indian Aluminium
the dispute related to classification of wire rods and not to manufacture
thereof and the issue before the Apex Court in Laminated Packagings
was whether the lamination of duty paid kraft paper amounted
to manufacture as kraft paper and laminated kraft paper were different
distinct commodities.
In
the present case flexible laminated film in jumbo roll is the same
commodity as flexible laminated films in smaller rolls
SC
decision in Kores India Ltd [2004-TIOL-92-SC-CX]
also not applicable as in that case the process resulted in emergence
of a ready to use product viz. "typewriter ribbon/telex ribbon"
while in the present case, the jumbo rolls were not cut to any specific
length but only slit lengthwise into specific widths. Cestat Larger
Bench;
2007-TIOL-774-CESTAT-BANG.doc
Central
Excise - Refund - Where the contract price is inclusive of duty
payable there cannot be unjust enrichment even if the duty payable
is either reduced or nil :Cestat;
SERVICE
TAX SECTION
stcir95.doc
GTO
Service - problems ironed out;
2007-TIOL-773-CESTAT-BANG.doc
Service
Tax - enormous correspondence between the appellant and the Revenue
on liability of service tax - demand of service tax by invoking
extended period is not sustainable as there is no suppression of
facts - appeal allowed solely on time bar :Cestat;
2007-TIOL-772-CESTAT-BANG.doc
Service
Tax - appellant engaged in the business of software sales, development,
maintenance, consultancy and training - service is classifiable
under consulting engineer service in view of the earlier CESTAT
order on identical issue. :Cestat;
CUSTOMS
SECTION
2007-TIOL-771-CESTAT-DEL.doc
Consignment
of secondary / defective material of mixed dimensions,
50% of which found to be rusted and not capable of being sold as
ferrous products, rightly classifiable as metal waste :Cestat; |