CENTRAL
EXCISE SECTION
2007-TIOL-93-HC-MAD-CX.doc
SCN - Recovery
of excess refund paid erroneously - Assessee pleads it is based
on Tribunal's order but fails to produce relied upon Order - 50%
deposit ordered under Sec 35F;
2007-TIOL-245-CESTAT-MUM-LB.doc
+
LB story.doc
Provisions of Rule 8 of the Valuation Rules will
not apply in a case where some part of the production is cleared
to independent buyers - Gunapradhan principle applied by SC in Ispat
Industries case applicable - Larger Bench;
Clarification by Board vide Circular dated 01.07.2002,
sr. no. 5, that valuation has to be done in terms of rule 9, proviso
thereto, in the manner specified in rule 8 improper;
Rule 8 would apply only in a case where its entire
production of a particular commodity is captively consumed - High
Court in the case of Indian Drug Manufacturers Association vs. Union
of India, wherein the Court held that Rule 8 applies in a situation
where goods are not sold but are cleared 'exclusively' to be used
in consumption or for manufacture of other articles relied upon;
If the intention was not to restrict the applicability
of rule 8 to cases where the entire production was being captively
consumed, the Rule 8 would have simply stated " where excisable
goods are consumed by an assessee himself or on his behalf "
instead of preceding the above expression with the words "
where the excisable goods are not sold";
2007-TIOL-243-CESTAT-AHM.doc
Central
Excise - Classification - Assessee manufactures plastic shelf with
multiple levels - Claims classification under Heading 3924.90 -
Revenue argues such shelf to be classified as 'other shelved furniture'
under Heading 9403.00 - HSN makes it clear that the household goods
made of plastic and generally kept on top of furniture or hung in
the wall are classifiable under Chapter Heading 39.24 - Demand also
hit by limitation;
2007-TIOL-242-CESTAT-MUM.doc
Clandestine
removal of modavatted inputs – plea that invoices were issued
only for the purpose of taking loan unsubstantiated as authenticity
of invoices admitted by Managing Director himself in his statements
which have not been retracted – Charges proved beyond doubt
– demand upheld;
SERVICE
TAX SECTION
2007-TIOL-244-CESTAT-KOL.doc
+
gymkhana story.doc
Mechanical
and statistical disposal of appeal by Commissioner (Appeals) - Remanded
for passing speaking order;
CUSTOMS
SECTION
2007-TIOL-241-CESTAT-AHM.doc
Import
of heavy metal scrap - Bill of entry filed - On examination Customs
finds 10% of consignment as re-rollable material - Since documents
supplied by foreign supplier and Inspection Certificate by accredited
agency mention only metal scrap, importer cannot be charged with
misdeclaration - Penalty u/s 112 set aside - But confiscation of
re-rollable materials upheld;
|